Coleman's Fish Market

Coleman's Fish Market in Wheeling. 4.5 rating · 453 reviews · $8. Coleman's Fish Market stands out for welcoming employees, convenient ordering (kiosks/app) and a convenient location. When it comes to the menu, look for well-seasoned fries, meals served nice and hot and meals that feel freshly prepared. Operationally, expect a clean dining area and good value for money. Heads up: rush periods can be hectic. Overall, a solid pick for a quick meal.

4.5 rating 453 reviews $8 Wheeling

2226 Market St 26003-3857

+13042330475

Coleman's Fish Market Coleman's Fish Market Coleman's Fish Market Coleman's Fish Market

Reviews

A quick look at recent guest feedback.

View all

ClaraKCMO

Jul 21, 2025 Tripadvisor
4/5
Quick stop, fresh fish!

This was easy to get to and easy access for us on a Monday! We tried a soft shell crab sandwich, the deluxe fish sandwich, deviled crab cake and alligator soup. The sandwiches were superior and incredibly reasonably priced! The fish sandwich had four pieces of...

Resort688977

Nov 1, 2024 Tripadvisor
5/5
Great lunch at Coleman’s

Took my elderly sister, who insisted we go, for lunch and it didn’t disappoint. Fresh fish sandwich and fries for a good value. We found street parking close enough for her to use her walker and get in and sit down. Go earlier to avoid a longer wait.

AlexPCPA

Sep 1, 2024 Tripadvisor
5/5
Fisch and Chicken Sandwiches

Coleman's Fish Market is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Their fish is always incredibly fresh and perfectly prepared, making every meal a delight. The knowledgeable staff offers excellent recommendations and top-notch service. The atmosphere is welcoming and...

Connector47613740363

Jul 13, 2024 Tripadvisor
3/5
PARKING RIDICULOUS

WE LEFT,LINES, PLUS NO.1 THE RIDIC PARKING,IT NEEDS TO BE LOCATED IN A LARGE PARKING LOT. PARK LOT IS A MILE AWAY!!! WE WERE FROM OUT OF TOWN

Tracey J

Feb 12, 2024 Tripadvisor
1/5
7$ Fish? sandwich don’t order ever

I wish I would have seen the reviews first before I tried the fish patty sandwich. Omg like someone else said you’re better off going to Mcdonalds at least they give you tarter sauce & cheese for the same price and it tastes better!! You get two little flat pa...

THINGS2LIVE4

Jan 2, 2024 Tripadvisor
5/5
Special

I travel frequently and look for unique restaurants that are affordable. Everything that I had here was 5 stars fries, slaw, mac and cheese, fish, and deviled crab. Wheeling is a unique towns with a lot of buildings from the 1800s. The area around the Whelling...

Gerard D

Nov 21, 2023 Tripadvisor
2/5
Wont be back

I usually love the food and atmosphere of Colemans. I haven't been there in a while and was SHOCKED at the amount of the price increases!! And the portions have dwindled as well. The fish was luke warm at best and the seasoned fries were cold. When I menti...

See something wrong?

Send a correction for this restaurant and we will review it.

Suggest an edit

Coleman's Fish Market

Incorrect data

Status

Sign in

Request access for Coleman's Fish Market.