Colemans Fish Market in Wheeling

Colemans Fish Market in Wheeling
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

2226 Market StWheeling WV 26003, Wheeling

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Seafood
  • Soups

Restaurant Hours

Monday

10:00 am - 5:30 pm

Tuesday

10:00 am - 5:30 pm

Wednesday

9:00 am - 5:30 pm

Thursday

9:00 am - 5:30 pm

Friday

8:30 am - 7:00 pm

Saturday

9:00 am - 5:30 pm

Sunday

Closed

Do they take credit cards?

yes they do

Do they have fish tacos??

They have fosh sandwiches and u can buy fresh fish and lobsters and they have fries and deviled crab

Can you get ,a fish sandwich on saturday

Yes

do they sell any gator meat there

No they don't

Do u ship live in nj was raised on your fish sandwich i miss them so much

No

Is Coleman's open on Memorial Day?

Coleman's closed on major holiday s

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Colemans Fish Market
Ivets
google
01.24.2021
5/5

Super delicious and fresh fish. Fried were seasoned and crispy. The"market" partt of the restaurant left a little too be desired, but then again, we're used to wholey's.

Colemans Fish Market
TY
Tom Yenk
google
10.25.2018
4/5

Had the well known fish sandwich and fries. Was served on plain white bread. Sandwich had two big pieces of fish on it and was fresh out of the oil. Fries were seasoned, hot and crispy.

Colemans Fish Market
SJ
Steve Jasko
google
10.21.2018
5/5

Great food and nice employees, but check your order before leaving. We have gotten take out several times only to get home and find out we didn't receive everything we ordered. When we called, they were kind enough to write our name down, and then gave us our missed items on our next trip.

Colemans Fish Market
KB
Katherine Ball
google
10.08.2018
5/5

Classical fresh fish market offering grilling or steaming of all fish sold. Known for their fried Canadian whitefish sandwiches but my favorite is the steamed, herbed whitefish with rice on vegetables.

Colemans Fish Market
SL
Stanley LiCalzi
google
09.21.2018
3/5

The fish sandwiches here were always so good , it was on my must do list at last visit I gagged on the first bite of my sandwich , the fish was so strong that I couldn't eat it . Always had either Canadian white fish or cod , this was neither .

Colemans Fish Market
JL
Jennifer Lofton
google
08.14.2018
5/5

The Canadian white fish sandwich in the special line was awesome! This was the first time I had it here.

Colemans Fish Market
LP
Lynette Parker
google
07.22.2018
5/5

Coleman's is a classic in the Wheeling area. People come from all over the place to get their fish sandwiches. The default is the pollock on bread. Period. I tend to get the whitefish and ad a touch of tarter sauce. It takes a little longer and you have to go through the special order line, but I really like it. They will serve it without the bread if you want (that's how I order it) or for a bit more they will serve it on a bun. Coleman's is in the historic market house and I remember being a tyke and shopping for produce there with my mom. There are lots of little shops across from the market house on both sides. Fun area to check out in addition to the really good fish sandwiches. BTW, they have all sorts of seafood and some other items you can order besides fish.

Colemans Fish Market
MR
Mark Reed
google
07.14.2018
5/5

. Easy ordering. Fish sandwiches awesome. Great experience. That was fun

Colemans Fish Market
Hd
HtiekraM deeR
google
05.22.2018
5/5

The line setup was a little confusing. But once I found the right place to go, everything went pretty smoothly. They got people in and out pretty easily. The fish sandwiches were awesome. It was my first time. It won't be my last time.

Colemans Fish Market
TB
Tilda Briggs
google
05.22.2018
5/5

Splendid food totally worth the wait and price.

Colemans Fish Market
TS
Tim Stanton
google
03.04.2018
5/5

If you are reading this you must stop now and just go if you want the best fish sandwich in the world...The best!!!

Colemans Fish Market
CB
Connie Burley
google
03.03.2018
5/5

They have the best fish sandwich I've ever had. I finally understand the hype. We only live about an hour away in Ohio. We'll be back soon and this time will take a bagful of sandwiches home.

Colemans Fish Market
BB
Bill Blinn
google
02.14.2018
5/5

This week I drove 4+ hour drive to Wheeling and back to Columbus for fish (and shrimp) sandwiches from Coleman's Fish Market and produce from Jebbia's Market. The shrimp sandwiches have 3 of the sweetest and most tasty shrimp you'll find. My photo shows just half a fish sandwich; Coleman's loads up the fish on the most bland white bread on the planet so that it doesn't interfere with the taste of the fish. If you visit Wheeling, make sure you stop for a sandwich and maybe buy a few more to take home. They'll prepare the order "bread separate" if you ask.

Colemans Fish Market
CM
Chad Mcleish
google
02.13.2018
5/5

Best old-fashioned fish sandwiches and sides. Pollock and Whitefish are their "normal" sandwiches. They have crab cakes and other popular menu items. Also has a LOT of specialty seafood available in their special order line. Don't go there for a dining experience, go there for a really good fiah sandwich and order the bread on the side!

Colemans Fish Market
jp
judi price
google
11.20.2017
5/5

Love their fish...like just watching people while I eat...lots of little shops in the area also

Colemans Fish Market
JT
Joyan Trubiano
google
11.02.2017
5/5

They have the best employees. Always so cheerful & helpful. The food being excellent is a big plus too.!

Colemans Fish Market
JR
Jeffrey Richards
google
10.10.2017
5/5

Coleman's has the best fish I've ever had anywhere. I'm not a huge fan of fish in general, but there is something special about their amazing fish sandwiches. If you've never had one, you won't be disappointed. Their seasoned fries are really good too. They have a huge selection of various seafood that is always fresh.

Colemans Fish Market
KW
Kyla Webb
google
09.26.2017
4/5

Food was good and shockingly low prices.

Colemans Fish Market
Elisegirl
google
09.06.2017
3/5

The cooks did not have mask on and that scared me and my family.

Colemans Fish Market
MG
Mae Gill
google
08.15.2017
5/5

My hubby has always loved Colemans

Colemans Fish Market
JY
Jill Yoho-White
google
07.25.2017
5/5

Please dont be discouraged if the line seems long. Remember it's because of the 6' rule and moves SUPER fast!

Colemans Fish Market
JP
Jenn Patterson
google
07.11.2017
4/5

Great fish sandwiches and sides. Prices a little high but still worth every penny.

Colemans Fish Market
BD
Bob DeMarsh, Jr.
google
07.11.2017
5/5

Outstanding fish sandwich. Heed the advice and go early, widely popular and for good reason.

Colemans Fish Market
CJ
Chuck Jones
google
06.27.2017
5/5

Lightly breaded fish, stacked high, on white bread. Who could ask for more!

Colemans Fish Market
Jm
John marvelle
google
06.24.2017
5/5

they have the best fish sandwich and u can get it uncooked and cook at home ( cheaper ) and u can buy uncooked on food stamps

Colemans Fish Market
PM
Patricia Millard
google
06.21.2017
5/5

Best fish sandwiches in the tri-state area also can buy fresh seafood or Pollock fish could not be beat

Colemans Fish Market
LO
Larry Oster
google
05.06.2017
5/5

Best fish in Wheeling....been going there since 1985

Colemans Fish Market
JW
Joanne Wright
google
03.22.2017
4/5

I bought a deviled crab and a fish sandwich. I was a little disappointed with the deviled crab this time. It was mushy and just wasn't seasoned the same. The fish was good but I missed the brown mustard.

Colemans Fish Market
SR
Shawn Rausch
google
03.18.2017
5/5

Fabulous fish sandwiches and great service!

Colemans Fish Market
RC
R C Pap Pap Lambert
google
02.21.2017
5/5

There is nowhere better than Coleman's Fish Market in Wheeling, WV for fish sandwiches and sides.We have yet to find anything to come near the quality, volume, and taste of the generous whitefish sandwich. Make it a point to visit them sometime in your life, your palate will thank you!

Colemans Fish Market
AD
Albert Dawson
google
01.22.2017
3/5

I ordered 2 fish sandwiches and prefer of fries. The fish was excellent and fresh. The only bad thing is the sandwiches come on sliced white bread and no tarter sauce. A fish sandwich should come on buns and come with tarter sauce unless ppl ask for no tarter .

Colemans Fish Market
FT
Faith Thomas
google
11.03.2016
5/5

First time here. Not bad, infact very good.Next time on my travels here I will be sure to stop in for a bite or two.I would recommend to anyone how passing though. Please stop in. You will not be disappointed.

Colemans Fish Market
DE
D E Halverson
google
09.10.2016
4/5

Limited selection but what they had was good at a good price. The fish sandwiches which we ordered first time exceeded our Hope's. We ordered six sandwiches and received enough fish to easily make over 16.

Colemans Fish Market
RH
Rick Harper
google
09.06.2016
4/5

Giant sized fish sandwich on a big whole wheat bun. Less than $6. Piping hot. Perfect!

Colemans Fish Market
fk
felicia kortepeter
google
07.25.2016
5/5

I was able to bring fresh fish home. It is all ready to fry in a little bit of oil. It was so delicious.

Colemans Fish Market
BT
Brian Thompson
google
07.14.2016
5/5

Best fish sandwich I have had.

Colemans Fish Market
DB
Darla Boyle
google
07.05.2016
4/5

The fish and fries were very good. The eating area was small but a nice group of people moved so our group could sit together. The young man kept the area clean as more customers came and went.

Colemans Fish Market
CF
Catie Fordyce
google
07.03.2016
5/5

Have been eating here since a child. One of the best places to eat in Ohio Valley! Best fish around! Fresh seafood, clean, and great service!

Colemans Fish Market
KS
Kenny Shively
google
07.02.2016
5/5

Best fish sandwich!

Colemans Fish Market
DH
Donella Hilbert
google
06.04.2016
5/5

Best fried fish around! Cole slaw also very tasty. Love their deviled crabs and spring rolls also! Can also get fish breaded to take home and fry.

Colemans Fish Market
NH
Nicole Hovanick
google
05.23.2016
5/5

Great fish sandwich. Fried oysters were excellent as well.

Colemans Fish Market
RS
Rick Simmonds
google
05.21.2016
5/5

So many friends said, you have to stop at Coleman's! So finally I have had the chance today. Wow! So good and did not disappoint

Colemans Fish Market
vn
vanessa norris
google
05.17.2016
5/5

This place is one of my top 3 favorite places to eat ever. Fast service and amazing fish sandwiches. I crave them on a regular! Fries are always on point and potatoes wedges are great too. A must see if you're traveling through the area!!!

Colemans Fish Market
cecilsmith24
google
03.04.2016
4/5

Definitely a good place to go and get fish. More varieties than what you might think. There are 2 different menus if you don't want the regular Coleman fish. I think you can also order just fish to take home and prepare. There is a dining area but not in the place, everything is pretty much takeout. Fries are good too.

Colemans Fish Market
JF
Janice Frees
google
02.10.2016
5/5

Excellent food! All kind of seafood, soups, fries, onion rings, Coleslaw, drinks and so much more. Can buy frozen and fresh seafood to take home.

Colemans Fish Market
rb
robert bennett
google
02.10.2016
5/5

Always good food and fast service.

Colemans Fish Market
AG
Adam Geer
google
02.02.2016
5/5

It's always been a part of my life. As a child growing up, I can remember going to the fish market with my grandfather to pick Coleman's fish with bread on the side. The food is as good now as it was then. When people come back to the valley to visit, they always have to stop at the fish market.

Colemans Fish Market
Lori
google
01.17.2016
3/5

Mediocre. My son ordered the soft shell crab sandwich and could not chew it... the shell was too hard. (I would love to include photos of obviously hard shell!) The cole slaw was good. We ordered crab cakes... got one cake that tasted like the dressing I make for holiday meals and had only a few tiny flakes of meat in them. The scallops were ok, but nothing to rave about.

Colemans Fish Market
LM
Lee Murphy
google
01.11.2016
1/5

Fish sandwich is WAY overrated, I mean the thing is served on dry wonder bread?!? Then they charge you 11 cents per tarter packet! Just wow. You don't have to travel any further than your nearest Burger King to find a better fish sandwich!

Colemans Fish Market
JZ
John Zillmann
google
01.05.2016
5/5

If you want to order the Canadian white fish sandwich you need to order from the special line to the left. You order then pay when they call your number, take your food to a table and enjoy.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13042330475

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!